Second Street Players 2025 presents

Coney Island
Christmas

written by Donald Margulies
based on the story "The Loudest Voice" by Grace Paley

directed by Rachel Loper and John H. Hulse

Fridays, NOV 28 and DEC 5 at 7:00p
Saturdays, NOV 29 and DEC 6 at 7:00p
Sundays, NOV 30 and DEC 7 at 2:00p

The Riverfront Theater
2 South Walnut Street  /  Milford, Delaware 19963
ABOUT THE SHOW...

Pulitzer Prize-winner Donald Margulies weaves together nostalgia, music and merriment in this new seasonal classic.

A holiday show for people of all ages and all faiths, CONEY ISLAND CHRISTMAS introduces us to Shirley Abramowitz, a young Jewish girl who (much to her immigrant parents’ exasperation) is cast as Jesus in the school’s Christmas pageant.

As Shirley, now much older, recounts the memorable story to her great-granddaughter, the play captures a timeless and universal tale of what it means to be an American during the holidays. Truly, a tale for all ages!


Gave me the gift of wonder…incredible enchantment!
—Los Angeles Times

A jewel…simply hilarious! —Variety

The biggest hit of the jam-packed holiday season!
—Backstage


About the Show...
Second Street Players  /  Riverfront Theater  /  2 South Walnut St.  /  Milford, DE 19963  / TIX: (302) 422-0220  /  info@secondstreetplayers.com
Reserved Seat Tickets: $17.00
A $1.00 Discount is offered to Seniors and Students for Sunday Matinees.

THE PRODUCTION TEAM

Co-Directors…   Rachel Loper and John H. Hulse
Producer…   Rachel Loper
Producer Mentor…   Ann Nichols
Assistant Director…   Alan Lane
Stage Manager…   Karen Marshall
Creative Associate…   Becky Craft
—Assistants to the Directors—
Michaela BowersoxEm Christianson
Assistant Stage Manager...   Isaac Christianson
Costumes…   Rosalynn GrayDoug James
Lighting Design…   Belle Marine
Lighting Tech…   Teagan Kneif
Photographers…   Becky CraftLen Willens
Set Design…   Ed O’Connor
—Set Construction Crew—
Ed O’Connor, Cast, Families, and Friends
Sound…   Lemuel Ferracci
Stage Crew…   Christine HittleLeslie Stevens
—Youth Supervisors—
Jill LewandowskiKori Lewandowski
Box Office…   Guy Crawford
—Fundraising—
Lauren DavidDulcena KemmerlinMelissa Brown
Julie GleasonRachel LoperJanine Valenti
Hospitality…   Tracy Dissinger
—Publicity—
SaraKate HammerLaura HowardAnn Nichols
Program…   Steven Haber
Website…   John Zinzi
SSP Administrative Assistant…   Suzanne Hamel



THE CAST OF CHARACTERS

In the present, Milford, Delaware
Great Grandmother Shirley Abramowitz…   Michele Blair
Clara…   Charli Rhine

During the Great Depression, Brooklyn, New York
Young Shirley Abramowitz…   Alyssa McKain
Mr. Misha Abramowitz…   Steven Haber
Mrs. Clara Abramowitz…  EJ Panico
Mrs. Kornblum…   Christine Rhine
Radio Voices…   Michael Forrest
Other Neighbors…   George BlairMichael Forrest 

At School
Mr. Hilton…   Mike McKain
Miss Glacé…   Mickenzie Davis
Teacher…   Christine Rhine
Jackie Sauerfeld…   Joseph Bradshaw
Evie Slotnick…   Kylie Montgomery
Ira Pushkov…   Aiden DePasquale
Anna Ling…   Ruby Miller
Henry Brown…   Rayne Davis
Lester…   Alex King
—Other Classmates—
Haley Attalian • Kaylee Cale • Lilly Enck • Sophia Graham
Jayce Hittle • Parker Rhine • Maelyn Torres • Madeleine Wright

In the Thanksgiving Pageant
Miles Standish…   Joseph Bradshaw
Priscilla Mullins…   Kylie Montgomery
King James…   Jayce Hittle
Squanto…   Rayne Davis
Statue of Liberty…   Aiden DePasquale
Turkey…   Alyssa McKain
Pilgrim #1…   Madeleine Wright
Pilgrim #2…   Maelyn Torres
Pilgrim Woman…   Haley Attalian
Other Pilgrim…   Kaylee Cale
—Other Indians—
Lilly Enck • Sophia Graham • Alex King
Ruby Miller • Parker Rhine

In the Coney Island Nightmare
Sideshow Hawker…   George Blair
Gypsy Fortune Teller…   Michael Forrest
Bearded Lady…   Christine Rhine
Siamese Twins…   Joseph Bradshaw & Aiden DePasquale
Dream Jesus…   EJ Panico

In the Christmas Pageant
Grandmother…   Haley Attalian
Jesus…   Alyssa McKain
Mary…   Kylie Montgomery
Joseph…   Joseph Bradshaw
Angel Gabriel…   Parker Rhine
Innkeeper…   Kaylee Cale
Shepherd #1…   Aiden DePasquale
Shepherd #2…   Maelyn Torres
King Herod…   Madeleine Wright
Wise Man #1…   Lilly Enck
Wise Man #2…   Jayce Hittle
Wise Man #3…   Ruby Miller
Santa Claus…   Rayne Davis
Ebenezer Scrooge…   Alex King
Ghost of Christmas Past…   Aiden DePasquale
Tiny Tim…   Sophia Graham


Coney Island Christmas is produced
through special arrangement with
Dramatists Play Service
440 Park Avenue South, New York, NY 10016
dpsinfo@broadwaylicensing.com

Reserved Seat Tickets: $27
$2.00 discount is offered to
Seniors, Students, and SSP Members
.